In 2006, democrats supported legislation to build border fence – the boston globe

Obama was talking about the Secure Fence Act of 2006, legislation authorizing a barrier along the southern border passed into law with the support of 26 Democratic senators including party leaders like Hillary Clinton, Joe Biden, and Chuck

Now it’s become the legal mechanism for Trump to order construction of a wall between the United States and Mexico, attempting to make good on a key promise from the campaign trail. D fence Trump specifically cited the law in the first sentence of Wednesday’s executive order authorizing the wall.

The episode shows how concerns over border security occupied Washington well before Trump made it the centerpiece of his candidacy, and that Democrats were more than willing to offer big sums of taxpayer money to keep Mexicans and other Latino immigrants out of the United States. Fencing forum The border fence called for in the 2006 law was far less ambitious than the wall Trump envisions, and, as he is apt to do, he has made the issue bigger, more explosive, and far more disruptive to US diplomacy.


Trump has also added his own twist that was never a part of the 2006 legislation, a promise that the Mexican people would pay for the wall. Garden design tool But on Thursday White House spokesman Sean Spicer, in a briefing aboard Air Force One, said that Trump would levy a 20 percent tax on all imports from Mexico to fund construction of the barrier.

He estimated that the 20 percent tariff would bring in $10 billion a year and “easily pay for the wall.” Later, the White House appeared to back away from the idea of an import tax.

Former Mexican president Vicente Fox, who opposed the measure in 2006 when he was in office, had even harsher words for Trump. Lattice multiplication method “Donald, don’t be self-indulgent,” he posted on his Twitter feed Thursday. Facebook search history public “Mexico has spoken, we will never ever pay for the #[Expletive]Wall.”

For Democrats who generally support relaxed rules that offer a path to citizenship for immigrants, the 2006 law was seen as the better of two evils. Yankee stadium food The House had recently passed legislation immigration advocates viewed as draconian because it would make any undocumented immigrant a felon.

“It didn’t have anywhere near the gravity of harm,” recalled Angela Kelley, who in 2006 was the legislative director for the National Immigration Forum. Basketball teams in texas “It was hard to vote against it because who is going to vote against a secure fence? And it was benign compared with what was out there.”

The law flew through the Senate with a vote of 80 to 19. Basketball olympics history (One senator, Edward Kennedy of Massachusetts, was not present. Uk basketball game score John Kerry, the state’s other senator, voted against it.) In the House, the measure passed 283 to 138, with 64 Democrats supporting it. Basketball wives la cast season 5 (The Massachusetts delegation was split.) From there it went to then-President George W. Fantasy football cheat sheet Bush, who signed it 12 days before the 2006 mid-term elections.

The plan was not nearly as expansive as Trump’s promise for a wall along the entire border. Basketball finals 2016 It allowed for about 700 miles of fencing along certain stretches. Dripping springs tx zip code Congress put aside $1.4 billion for the fence, but the whole cost, including maintenance, was pegged at $50 billion over 25 years, according to analyses at the time.

The government had constructed about 650 miles of fence by 2015, most of it after passage of the act, according to a report last year by the US Government Accountability Office.

In his 2006 floor speech, Obama nodded to the prevailing belief in Washington that the bill wasn’t going anywhere. Paving block crossword “This bill, from my perspective, is an election-year, political solution,” he said. Ncaa basketball final four history “It is great for sound bites and ad campaigns.”

Clinton also voted for the bill, though in a floor speech during the debate she completely ignored the fence issue and heaped praise on an amendment to it that would help New York farmers by expanding the number of visas allowed for agricultural workers.

“I voted numerous times when I was a senator to spend money to build a barrier to try to prevent illegal immigrants from coming in,” Clinton said at November 2015 town hall in New Hampshire, “and I do think that you have to control your borders.”

“There was a lot of analysis done that said you just can’t do it,” said Kelley, who worked on the bill and is now the Executive Director of Center for American Progress Action Fund. Garden ideas for front of house “It was more a political statement than a sound policy proposal.”

“A lot of people owned land [where the fence would go]. High pitch sound effect There were endangered squirrels. Pro landscape None of that was being dealt with. Baseball teams in florida It really did feel like this was more of a slogan than a solution,” said Kelley.

Only one current Democratic leader voted against the bill: That’s Bernie Sanders, who was in the House of Representatives at the time. Gardens illustrated subscription He didn’t make a statement about it one way or the other, and his spokesman, Michael Briggs, declined to comment Thursday.

From the floor he bemoaned the death of a larger bipartisan overhaul to the immigration system and mocked the Republicans for coming up with legislation he felt would do little to fix the problem.

“Republican leaders wasted time, opportunity, and your money,” Kennedy said. Trellis restaurant menlo park “For a $9 billion fence that won’t do the job. Basketball olympics winners That is just a bumper sticker solution for a complex problem. Softball drills for beginners It’s a feel-good plan that will have little effect in the real world.”

Advocates jammed the phone lines, and even sent members of Congress bricks that were intended to symbolize the wall they wanted constructed on the southern border, according to a Washington Post story from the time.

“We do not have operational control of the border,” Sessions said during the 2006 debate. Asphalt driveway thickness “Fencing on the southern border is and should be a part of our plan to recapture a legal system of immigration in America. All baseball teams It remains one of our important priorities.”

All materials are found on open spaces of a network the Internet as freely extended and laid out exclusively in the fact-finding purposes. If you are what lawful legal owner or a product and against its placing on the given site, inform us and we will immediately remove the given material. The administration of a site does not bear responsibility for actions of the visitors breaking copyrights. abuzesite@bigmir.net